Abstract
Background
Although mandatory reporting has grown substantially in scope and geographical coverage, there is limited empirical evidence to support its effectiveness in preventing harm to children. In the absence of rigorous evaluations, comparing the perspectives of individuals who work in systems with and without mandatory reporting provides important insights.
Objective
The purpose of this analysis was to compare perspectives of frontline workers, administrators, and experts in child abuse and neglect in a system with mandatory reporting (Colorado, United States) and one without mandatory reporting (The Netherlands).
Methods
We conducted a total of 64 interviews with 77 participants. We used an iterative and team-based approach to code all interview transcripts. For this manuscript, we focused on codes and themes related to mandatory reporting.
Results
Overall, we found much disagreement on mandatory reporting both within and across the two systems. Some participants identified that mandatory reporting could prevent communities from intervening, damage therapeutic relationships, and be overly intrusive to families. Others thought mandatory reporting was a meaningful way to increase the identification of maltreated children and reduce the burden on individuals and systems outside of child protection. Individuals’ perspectives on local communities as either a partner in responding to maltreatment or as a conduit for referrals shaped their opinions.
Conclusions
Evaluation of the outcomes of mandatory reporting policies is critical, and our work highlights factors to consider when implementing or modifying mandatory reporting policies and practices.
Similar content being viewed by others
Availability of data and material
Due to privacy regulations, the interview transcriptions may not be shared outside of the research team.
References
Ainsworth, F. (2002). Mandatory reporting of child abuse and neglect: does it really make a difference? Child & Family Social Work, 7(1), 57–63
Baartman, H. E. M. (2008). Assessment of children’s safety in child and youth care - In the context of ideology, policy, and organization. In E. J. Knorth, et al. (Ed.), The development of children with problems: Simply different (pp. 80–94). Garant Publishers
Bradley, E. H., Curry, L. A., & Devers, K. J. (2007). Qualitative data analysis for health services research: Developing taxonomy, themes, and theory. Health Services Research, 42(4), 1758–1772
Brown, L. G., & Gallagher, K. (2013). Mandatory reporting of abuse: A historical perspective on the evolution of states’ current mandatory reporting laws with a review of the laws in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Villanova Law Review Online: Tolle Lege, 59, 37–42
California Evidence-Based Clearinghouse (2021). Strong communities for children. CEBC. https://www.cebc4cw.org/program/strong-communities-for-children/detailed
Charmaz, K. (2006). Constructing grounded theory: A practical guide through qualitative analysis. Sage
Christopherson, R. J. (1981). Two approaches to the handling of child abuse: A comparison of the English and Dutch systems. Child Abuse & Neglect, 5(4), 369–373
Dharmasena, S., & Capps, O. (2012). Intended and unintended consequences of a proposed national tax on sugar-sweetened beverages to combat the US obesity problem. Health Economics, 21(6), 669–694
Dinardo, J., & Lemieux, T. (2001). Alcohol, marijuana, and American youth: the unintended consequences of government regulation. Journal of Health Economics, 20(6), 991–1010
Gilbert, N., Parton, N., & Skivenes, M. (Eds.). (2011). Child protection systems: International trends and orientations: Oxford
Goodrick, D. (2014). Comparative Case studies, Methodological Briefs: Impact Evaluation 9, UNICEF Office of Research, Florence
Graneheim, U. H., & Lundman, B. (2004). Qualitative content analysis in nursing research: concepts, procedures and measures to achieve trustworthiness. Nurse Education Today, 24(2), 105–112
Ho, G. W. K., Gross, D. A., & Bettencourt, A. (2017). Universal mandatory reporting policies and the odds of identifying child physical abuse. American Journal of Public Health, 107(5), 709–716
Hsieh, H. F., & Shannon, S. E. (2005). Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qualitative Health Research, 15(9), 1277–1288
Institute of Medicine & National Research Council. (2014). New Directions in Child abuse and Neglect Research. The National Academies Press
Krase, K. S., & DeLong-Hamilton, T. A. (2015). Comparing reports of suspected child maltreatment in states with and without universal mandated reporting. Children and Youth Services Review, 50, 96–100
Lamond, D. A. P. (1989). The impact of mandatory reporting legislation on reporting behavior. Child Abuse & Neglect, 13(4), 471–480
López López, M., Bouma, H., Knorth, E. J., & Grietens, H. (2019). The Dutch child protection system: Historical overview and recent transformations. In L. Merkel-Holguin, J. Fluke, & R. D. Krugman (Eds.), National systems of child protection (pp. 173–192). Springer Netherlands
Mathews, B. (2015). Mandatory reporting laws: Their origin, nature, and development over time. In B. Mathews, & D. C. Bross (Eds.), Mandatory reporting laws and the identification of severe child abuse and neglect (pp. 3–25). Springer Netherlands
Mathews, B., Bromfield, L., & Walsh, K. (2020). Comparing reports of child sexual and physical abuse using child welfare agency data in two jurisdictions with different mandatory reporting laws. Social Sciences, 9(5), 75–97
Mathews, B., & Kenny, M. C. (2008). Mandatory reporting legislation in the United States, Canada, and Australia: A cross-jurisdictional review of key features, differences, and issues. Child Maltreatment, 13(1), 50–63
Mathews, B., Lee, J., & Norman, X., R. E (2016). Impact of a new mandatory reporting law on reporting and identification of child sexual abuse: A seven year time trend analysis. Child Abuse & Neglect, 56, 62–79
McDonell, J. R., Ben-Arieh, A., & Melton, G. B. (2015). Strong Communities for Children: Results of a multi-year community-based initiative to protect children from harm. Child Abuse & Neglect, 41, 79–96
McLeigh, J. D., McDonell, J. R., & Melton, G. B. (2015). Community differences in the implementation of Strong Communities for Children. Child Abuse & Neglect, 41, 97–112
McTavish, J. R., Kimber, M., Devries, K., Colombini, M., Macgregor, J. C. D., Wathen, C. N., & Macmillan, H. L. (2017). Mandated reporters’ experiences with reporting child maltreatment: a meta-synthesis of qualitative studies. BMJ Open, 7(10), e013942
McTavish, J. R., Kimber, M., Devries, K., Colombini, M., Macgregor, J. C. D., Wathen, N., & Macmillan, H. L. (2019). Children’s and caregivers’ perspectives about mandatory reporting of child maltreatment: a meta-synthesis of qualitative studies. BMJ Open, 9(4), e025741
Melton, G. B., & McLeigh, J. D. (2020). The nature, logic, and significance of strong communities for children. International Journal on Child Maltreatment: Research, Policy and Practice, 3, 125–161
National Conference of State Legislatures (2021). Differential response in child protective services: Analysis of state legislative provisions.https://www.ncsl.org/research/human-services/state-legislation-differential-response.aspx
Netherlands Youth Institute. (2007). Youth policy in the Netherlands: An overview of policies, structures, and provisions concerning children and young people living in the Netherlands. Author
Palusci, V. J., & Vandervort, F. E. (2014). Universal reporting laws and child maltreatment report rates in large US counties. Children and Youth Services Review, 38, 20–28
Raman, S., & Hodes, D. (2012). Cultural issues in child maltreatment. Journal of Paediatrics and Child Health, 48(1), 30–37
Rijksoverheid (2017). Basismodel meldcode huiselijk geweld en kindermishandeling [Basic model reporting code domestic violence and child abuse]. Retrieved from https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/documenten/rapporten/2017/01/09/basismodel-meldcode-huiselijk-geweld-en-kindermishandeling
Roberts, A. W., Farley, J. F., Holmes, G. M., Oramasionwu, C. U., Ringwalt, C., Sleath, B., & Skinner, A. C. (2016). Controlled substance lock-in programs: examining an unintended consequence of a prescription drug abuse policy. Health Affairs, 35(10), 1884–1892
Schene, P. A. (1998). Past, present, and future roles of child protective services. The Future of Children, 8(1), 23–38
Steen, J. A., & Duran, L. (2014). Entryway into the child protection system: the impacts of child maltreatment reporting policies and reporting system structures. Child Abuse & Neglect, 38(5), 868–874
US Advisory Board on Child Abuse and Neglect. (1991). Creating caring communities: Blueprint for an effective federal policy on child abuse and neglect. US Department of Health and Human Services
US Advisory Board on Child Abuse and Neglect. (1993). Neighbors helping neighbors: A new national strategy for the protection of children. US Department of Health and Human Services
Van Dam, B. A. F. M., Van Der Sanden, W. J. M., & Bruers, J. J. M. (2015). Recognizing and reporting domestic violence: attitudes, experiences and behavior of Dutch dentists. BMC Oral Health, 15, 159. doi: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12903-015-0141-4
van Ruller, E. (1981). The confidential doctor in The Netherlands. Child Abuse & Neglect, 5, 491–493
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to our Dutch colleagues, without whom this study would have been impossible. Lieke Sparidaens interviewed Dutch Child Protection workers and transcribed their interviews; Cees Hoefnagles assisted with the interview protocol; Peter van der Linden and Paul Baeten helped identify the Dutch Child Protection and other Government workers who were interviewed. This study was funded by the Nancy and Sam Gary Family Foundation.
Funding
This study was funded by the Nancy and Sam Gary Family Foundation.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
None.
Ethics Approval
This study was approved by the Colorado Multiple Institutional Review Board.
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Schwab-Reese, L.M., Albright, K. & Krugman, R.D. Mandatory Reporting “will Paralyze People” or “Without it, People Would not Report”: Understanding Perspectives from Within the Child Protection System. Child Youth Care Forum 52, 139–156 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10566-022-09676-y
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10566-022-09676-y